This Trial Ain’t Nothing But A Sham — Reviewing ‘Barbara Gordon: Breakout’ #7

by Scott Redmond

Overview

Like a roller coaster, Barbara Gordon’s series continues it’s path of seemingly random highs and lows. Like the theme park rides, it has a destination even if that end point is still nebulously unclear.

Overall
8.5/10
8.5/10

While the authoritarian reign of one Vandal Savage has come to an end, ripples of his schemes remain in play. No where more prevalent than within the walls of the super-max prison he stuffed criminals and innocents alike.

A desperate life-threatening gamble is enacted as Two-Face prepares to dispense demented deadly justice in Barbara Gordon: Breakout #7. Pieces of the mysterious puzzle remain shadowy as Mariko Tamaki, Pablo M. Collar, Tamra Bonvillain, and Ariana Maher continue this prison based drama.

Sometimes comics, or just stories in general, end up in this strange nebulous middle space. They aren’t the most thrilling or life-changing of thing but they also aren’t terrible or worth throwing on a cut pile. There are bright spots and flaws a plenty in pretty balanced respects. It’s sort of like the proverbial scales that Two-Face claims to want to balance, with his warped sense of justice.

As a writer, I enjoy what Tamaki puts down more often than not. Her previous reign of writing Gotham related works — particularly a wonderful run of Detective Comics — is something I still think of at times. It was very engaging and built upon itself and the world around it to say many things. We got a whole Arkham Tower saga multi-part event out of it that was good stuff.

This series though, well it confounds me.

There are great character beats and moments. It’s been showing that Tamaki knows her characters and their spaces within this world well. The addition of Savant and Creote, former-adversaries-turned-allies of Gordon and her Birds of Prey, has been great. Everything to do with Two-Face and Harvey Dent’s current dynamic and back and forth was spot on.

At the same time, we’re seven issues in and there is still nothing but hints and vague inferences to the whole mystery of the series. Someone or something has been killing, trying to kill, or saving Barbara since the start. We know nothing more about this mystery now than we did then, other than two issues in a row indicating something is off about the walls.

I have no clue how long this book is set to last, with the aforementioned Vandal Savage reign that kicked it off now over in other books. For its sake I hope that this issue’s big cliffhanger moment finally leads us to some answers.

Discovering unfamiliar artists is always a nice thing when reading through comics. There are far too many comics being published for anyone to be up on all of them, so there are always artists that might have been doing other things or recently broken in that are a welcome find. Collar is one of those artists for myself, as I don’t recall seeing their work before.

That being said, I like what I see here.

I would say that the work very much fits in that perfect space between standard heroic smoothness and a more street-level rough texture. It’s befitting of a book that is seeing a hero trying to survive the harshness of a super prison under the thumb of an ancient villain. It’s got some more unique elements which border on exaggeration with proportions which are almost natural but just slightly off, giving characters a more sharp or distinct look at times.

Action feels very energetic, as figures are moving through the dense space with ease. Enough details and density are being created to allow the overall space to feel alive and authentic. Connected to this feeling is the naturalized and slightly even toned color palette from Bonvillain. There are still some of the richer vibrant colors that she’s utilized in more heroic books, but they are tempered with the rougher textures. It fits into the overall tone without losing the distinct elements which are a hallmark of her particular coloring style.

Speaking of a particular style and well, speaking, there is always something visually distinct and fun when Maher is lettering. She slips in bubbles, fonts, and elements which enrich the visuals while giving characters the correct energy to their voices, like the ragged bubbles which are common for someone like Two-Face and his (assumed) gravelly type of voice. She lets it all flow through the pages with grace and logical placement that borders the eye line path of any given page.

Barbara Gordon: Breakout #7 is now available from DC Comics.