True Ugliness Lives Within — Reviewing ‘Clayface: Celebrity Dirty’ #5
by Scott Redmond
Overview
Things take a very personal turn as the intriguing and dark journey centered on one of Batman’s most unusual group of rogues continues. Every element of the series builds upon one another in the most rich and intriguing of ways, tapping well into the heavier elements on every visual level.
Overall
9/10Time and time again, the worst kinds of men prove why they and others like them are nothing but threats. Entitled, full of rage and harmful intent, they blame any of their flaws or issues on the women they decide owe them something.
Imagine one of those “incel” types ending up with a terrible power to be anyone they want, and using it to murder and harm others. That’s where things currently stand in Clayface: Celebrity Dirt #5, the issue where the full story of the dueling Basil Karlos starts to take shape. It’s another hard and illuminating chapter from Jude Ellison S. Doyle, Fran Galán, Patricio Delpeche, and Tom Napolitano.
![]()
What a story that is being woven here!
Doyle holds not a single punch as the revealed Clayface known as Preston Payne embodies just about every toxic trait held by too many men. At the same time, the way this story weaves together the varying eras of Clayfaces together into a clear pantheon is masterful. Characters who were introduced at different times as riffs on one another now have clearer connections. Their threads extend from each other to various Batman related stories told over the decades.
It’s a really mesmerizing dance between the raindrops Doyle is pulling off. It demonstrates some continuity and character writing chops that are on par with so many other writers. Not a shock since all of Doyle’s original stories I’ve read and reviewed have shown the bona fides. Moving from original work to swimming in the vast pools that are DC or Marvel is not the easiest, and not everyone is meant to be a canon master.
![]()
Clearly, Doyle was meant to wield this power and employs it in the best ways possible.
Hittings the right horrific-and-simultaneously-down-to-Earth vibe is key to a story like this. Not a tall order for Galán, who nails every mark. Describing the artwork would be best if I said that it has dense figures that feel solid yet malleable at the same time. It is very much the aesthetic of each and every single one of the Clayfaces.
I love the choices for paneling and how they give a sense of space while also heightening the tense horror of the series. The last pages, where we see the two Basil Karlos and one of them turns back into Clayface, are beyond perfectly creepy. Consider the partying bar crowd standing there, kind of in the way.
![]()
Matching that mood is the color palette, which melts from light to dark in an instant. It all keeps the colors in a very borderline washed-out-almost-watercolor styled appearance. Delpeche nails bringing in more vibrant hues to boost moments while surrounding them in thicker, darker colors that work as a frame and enhancer. Fantastical meets the real world in every way possible; that would be my best choice of descriptor.
Rounding out the visually stunning work is the stylishly smooth work of Napolitano, one of the letterers I enjoy seeing on any and every title. The way it all just flows and builds is undeniably perfect. Playing at being casual and almost unnoticeable as lettering is thought to be best before bouncing in with a harder and hard-to-miss beat. Here, it lets the character’s energy burst onto the page, especially with the way that the Clayfaces talk and have their bubbles.
I have no clue where this is all going, but I’m very locked-in on following the story until the very end.
Clayface: Celebrity Dirt #5 is now available from DC Comics.