A Murder Most Foul And Confusing — Reviewing ‘Detective Comics’ #1115

by Scott Redmond

Overview

Living up to it’s name, ‘Detective Comics’ #1115 provides a good solid turnaround for the series as this new, murderous arc begins. All visuals are on point, per usual, as the dynamic energy of this run continues to hit the right spot.

Overall
9/10
9/10

When it comes to the pantheon of superheroes, few are as virtuous and universally beloved as Superman. He is a figure who stands tall for what is right and one that would never cross the line of harm or murder.

Unfortunately, that might not be fully the case anymore.

All signs point to Clark Kent when a murder happens in Smallville, leading Batman to investigate the guilt or innocence of his friend. Detective Comics #1115 kicks off a whole new arc from Tom Taylor, Mikel Janín, and Wes Abbott.

-SPOILERS FOLLOW-

Now this is the kind of story I’ve been waiting for. Funny that it’s apparently the now-solicited final arc from this creative team.

Through the last year or so there have been a lot of ups and downs with the current run, most of them focused on pulling out various retcons or mysterious figures connected to Batman. Going a bit light on both the detective part of the series’ name as well as sticking to the present day. One thing that I’ve maintained that whole time: Taylor writes a good Bruce Wayne and a good Batman.

While we only see the latter in this first issue, the world’s greatest detective beats are on full display. We also get to see Taylor dabble in the figure that is Superman and Clark Kent; demonstrating how both are perceived in their circles while also tapping into a bit of current League stuff. There is a very natural, almost predictable flow to how this story unfolds. “Predictable” being a good thing in this particular case as it is more centered on the story beats having very familair murder case elements.

As they say, the vibes are right with this one.

Having Clark be uncertain to whether he committed the murder or not adds an additional wrinkle to the whole affair. I appreciate this as it makes it more than just Clark turning himself in because he wants to follow rules and protect his identity. One of the most powerful figures for good being uncertain if he committed a crime is a good cliffhanger.

Tapping Janín for this run continues to be one of the best choices that was made all around. His is a style which fits not only the character, but the mood for a variety of story types. The work is very authentic in the presentation of figures and mixed with tangible emotional and kinetic energies. Each space occupied feels genuine in scope and scale, giving the whole world and story more gravity.

Clark Kent being taller and bigger than others comes off well in this style, highlighting how different characters are from one another. Their presence, whether they are minor or major, is not taken lightly.

How the investigation elements are incorporated is very much a chef kiss moment. Batman can see how the body was dropped and found — and thanks to the artistic choices, so do we. Skipping side-flashes or flashbacks to have the body disposal theories play out as transparent images around the ‘real’ world spaces was inspired as a choice.

Similarly, the light-but-heavy tone Janín brings to colors works on various levels. It keeps to a more natural palette which dabbles in heavy and light in equal measures, and befits the overall series’ tone, utilizing so many angles of the spectrum to breathe life into a space or character. And it lets different lighting or the overall space be the deciding factor in whether something needs more or less vibrancy in this often overly-bright heroic medium.

Most of the big talking moments occur centered around Clark or Superman, leaving the more internal and silent moments to the naturally and more introspective Batman. Abbott delivers the scripted words with emotional and empathetic precision. Each resonant moment recorded with body language or facial expression is matched by the lettering choices.

I love a good detective internal accounting, and we get a pretty good one here. Batman investigates and walks us, the audience, through his process.

Detective Comics #1115 is now available from DC Comics.