Commentary: ‘Cosmic Detective’s Story Isn’t As Strong As Its Journey
by Frank Martin
Sometimes the story isn’t the most important aspect of a project. Of course, writers want strong characters and a plot that resonates with its audience. But storytelling experiences are so much more than that. There can be great music, comedy, action, and special effects that provide the audience with a worthwhile experience, even if the story is lacking. For comic books, great art can take the reader on a journey even if the story isn’t firing on all cylinders. Written by Jeff Lemire and Matt Kindt, Cosmic Detective is a great example of a book where the visual experience makes up for shortcomings in its story.
The title follows an unnamed detective whose job is, essentially. to keep the existence of an all-powerful alien race a secret on Earth. This means covering up their tracks while utilizing advanced technology. The plot begins when one such being is murdered, something that was thought impossible. The detective investigates the murder and learns that the entity impregnated a human woman. While attempting to rescue her, he discovers that the aliens are really using Earth as a gas station and will destroy the planet when they inevitably move on.
There are enough familiar noir and detective tropes to keep the reader engaged. It also has a theme of existential crisis to give it depth. But there is room for improvement. The story could have been a little bit tighter and benefited from further editing. But that doesn’t detract from the overall experience. The art by David Rubin is wild. The premise of these godlike beings allows for mind-bending alterations to reality. The detective experiences an incredible journey that shakes the very fabric of his existence to its core. So while the story itself left something to be desired, the journey the art takes the reader on still provides a wild read.
Cosmic Detective is now available from Image Comics.
