Not Enough Carole Lombard: A Mini Review Of ‘We’re Not Dressing’ (1934)

by Rachel Bellwoar

Like a conventional version of Sam Raimi’s Save Me without the gender flip on expectations over who will fare better on a deserted island, Norman Taurog‘s We’re Not Dressing is about a sailor named Stephen (Bing Crosby) who works on a boat owned by Carole Lombard (sporting a very poodle-ish hairstyle at the beginning of this movie). Other passengers aboard include Ray Milland as one of Lombard’s suitors and Broadway legend Ethel Merman. 

 

 

For some reason, the boat sinks. It shouldn’t. There’s drinking involved, but even bearing that in mind, it doesn’t really make sense why the outcome is so catastrophic. Regardless, they all wind up on a deserted island, and the question becomes whether the stubborn Doris (Lombard) will admit she needs Stephen’s help. There’s also the question of whether class differences are enough to keep these two apart or if love can see past income.

Investment in this obviously meant-to-be-together couple will vary, and a lot of the film is people sitting around, listening to Crosby sing. There’s also way too much screen time devoted to Doris’ pet bear. Sure, it’s a little amusing to see all of the edits between a real bear, a person in a bear suit, and a stuffed animal, but a bear should never be stealing focus from Lombard, whose comic talents aren’t fully utilized by this movie.

 

 

George and Gracie Burns get the most laughs when it’s revealed the island isn’t completely devoid of people after all, but for a Carole Lombard movie where economic differences threaten to get in the way of romance, My Man Godfrey is light years better than this weirdly-titled musical comedy. If like me, however, a new Lombard movie on Blu-ray is too good to pass up, We’re Not Dressing is available now from Universal and can be purchased from Movie Zyng.