Commentary: What ‘Backrooms’ Could Have Learned From ‘Pirates Of The Caribbean’

by Frank Martin

When films are derived from an experience rather than a story, extra care has to be given to develop meaningful plot and characters. A great example of this: Disney’s Pirates of the Caribbean. The original film was based on the classic Disney ride, which featured a slight story and no prominent characters. It was more an experience of taking riders through an age of piracy. Only later were elements unique from the film incorporated into the attraction. In many ways, Backrooms derives from an experience as well. Its popularity largely comes from the tension of exploring liminal spaces, and it should have followed the example Pirates of the Caribbean set to develop a more meaningful story.

After finding success through a series of YouTube videos, Backrooms developed into a feature-length film about two characters: a depressed furniture salesman named Clark (Chiwetel Ejiofor) and his therapist, Mary (Renate Reinsve). While investigating the basement of his store, Clark finds a bizarre space of never-ending rooms that defy physics. After telling Mary that he is going to stay there forever, she goes in search of him, but he kidnaps her inside. He then explains how believes the backrooms to be a place of memories that are not quite right. They are attacked by a monstrous pirate version of Clark. After a chase, Mary escapes with the aid of a mysterious organization called Async that investigates the backrooms.

The Pirates of the Caribbean franchise succeeded because of two main components. 1.) An undeniably charismatic character with 2.) an intricate backstory to expand upon in future installments. By contrast, Backrooms barely gave audiences a nibble of its own mythology. Clark speculated as to what he believed the nature of the backrooms to be, but it was never solidified or even realized in depth. Also, Async was established as an organization with ties to the backrooms, but even their history and purpose weren’t explored as much as they could have been. Of course, the film wanted to leave a bit of mystery to the phenomenon, but they could have done that while giving audiences more ways to be immersed in the lore of the world.

Backrooms is now streaming on HBO Max.