Commentary: ‘Beetlejuice, Beetlejuice’ Puts Nostalgia Before Story
by Frank Martin
With the demand of nostalgia at an all-time high, it’s inevitable for studios to revisit some fan favorite properties for revival. But it’s important not just to remain true to the spirits of the franchise and its characters, but also to deliver a compelling story. Beetlejuice Beetlejuice is a great example of how long-awaited sequels can go awry. The film checks off a lot of boxes by bringing back stars Michael Keaton, Winona Ryder, and Catherine O’Hara. Also, it made the right move placing Tim Burton at the helm and bringing in beloved horror newcomer Jenna Ortega. But despite scratching the Beetlejuice itch that fans have had for all these years, the story could have been much stronger than it was.
The film takes place decades after the first with Lydia all grown up and with a child of her own named Astrid. It begins as her grandfather dies on a trip, thus triggering a return to the town from the original film. While she is there against her will, Astrid meets a boy whom she connects with. Unfortunately, he’s a ghost who murdered his parents and tricks Astrid into swapping places with him in the afterlife. In order to save her, Lydia calls upon Beetlejuice, who has schemes of his own to marry Lydia once and for all.
Fans of the original will love seeing all of these characters again. They will also love to be back into this bizarre version of the afterlife. Keaton once again shines as Beetlejuice and provides some truly hilarious moments. Unfortunately, the film is really nothing more than a series of those moments as there’s no cohesive story to tie it all together. There’s also a side plot involving Beetlejuice’s ex-wife (Monica Bellucci) who is out for revenge. But this plot never ties in with the other characters. All of the storylines feel disjointed, operating independently of one another without any real consequence. So it’s nice to see these beloved franchises getting a second life, but it would be better if there was some actual compelling storytelling behind it.
Beetlejuice Beetlejuice is now in theaters.
