Advance Review — ‘The Eye Collector’ #6 Remains A Visual Masterpiece
by Tom Smithyman
Overview
This horror series is a visual extravaganza. Yet it would be so much more complete if the story were just a bit clearer. The situations and reasons behind characters’ behaviors are sometimes impenetrable, which make it difficult to enjoy the series.
Overall
8.5/10Real horror is seeing something sinister that no one else can. The killer hiding in the shadows. An animal quietly stalking its prey. A doomed race ignoring the obvious signs of its own destruction.
![]()
Artist GMB Chomichuk seems to embrace this idea, making The Eye Collector all the more frightening. From the opening pages of this sixth issue, Chomichuk, who also writes the story along with Jonathan Ball, lets us know there are sinister forces at work in young Nathan’s world.
Shadows of Nathan and his friend Clara morph into otherworldly creatures. Another ominous shadow appears out of nowhere, unseen by the children.
![]()
Of course, we already know that all is not right in Nathan’s world. His mother and father have seemingly handed him over to the Eye Collector, the mysterious creature who inhabits their dreams. This would-be Sandman also has his sights set on Clara. Now, Nathan goes to battle against the Collector in the final issue of this story arc.
As has been the case throughout this visually stunning series, the illustrations make the story. The tale itself is opaque. While interesting, it’s largely impenetrable. Is the Eye Collector an alien from the moon? Why does he want eyes? Why are Nathan’s parents seemingly complicit in the act? It’s doubtful we’ll ever get satisfying answers to these questions.
![]()
If that bothers you, then you probably abandoned this series several issues ago. Unless, of course, Chomichuk’s stunning visuals keep you coming back for more. They remain the high point of both this issue and the series. From the details of Nathan’s father’s suit to the sometimes-blurry imagery to the hidden details and words throughout the panels, Chomichuk is staking out his place as a master visual storyteller.
![]()
If this series were more straightforward, he would probably collect more eyeballs. For now, though, he’ll have to make do with a story that’s difficult to peer into.
![]()
The Eye Collector #6 — written by Jonathan Ball and GMB Chomichuk, illustrated by Chomichuk, and lettered by Lyndon Radchenka — will be available Wednesday in comic book stores and on digital platforms from Image Comics.